Negotiating With Insurance Companies On Behalf Of The Plaintiff
Negotiating with insurance companies for your personal injury claim can be complex and overwhelming. It is crucial to understand your rights and the tactics insurers often employ to minimize claims. We will explain the role of insurance companies in your personal injury case, essential elements of a strong negotiation strategy, factors to consider when deciding to accept a settlement, and the potential outcomes of litigation in these types of cases.
Discover how experienced representation from the team of trusted personal injury lawyers in Flagstaff, AZ could help you successfully navigate these negotiations and pursue fair compensation.
YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO REPRESENTATION IN
PERSONAL INJURY CASES
Negotiating with insurance companies for your personal injury claim can be complex and overwhelming. It is crucial to understand your rights and the tactics insurers often employ to minimize claims. We will explain the role of insurance companies in your personal injury case, essential elements of a strong negotiation strategy, factors to consider when deciding to accept a settlement, and the potential outcomes of litigation in these types of cases.
Discover how experienced representation from Antol & Sherman’s personal injury law team can help you successfully navigate these negotiations and pursue fair compensation.
Understanding the Role of Insurance Companies
When you file a claim for injuries sustained in an accident, you are essentially seeking compensation from the at-fault party’s insurance company. Understanding how insurance companies operate can help you navigate the negotiation process more effectively.
Insurance companies aim to minimize payouts and protect their interests by employing various tactics, such as:
Claims Investigations: Insurance companies conduct thorough investigations into claims to determine liability and assess the extent of damages. They may use this information to justify offering a lower settlement amount.
Low Settlement Offers: Insurers often make initial settlement offers that are lower than the actual value of your claim. They hope that you will accept the offer out of desperation or lack of knowledge about your rights.
Delays: Insurance companies may delay the claims process to put pressure on you to accept a lower settlement. They may request unnecessary documentation or drag out negotiations.
Liability Disputes: In some cases, insurers may dispute liability or argue that you were partially at fault for the accident. This tactic is used to reduce the amount they have to pay you.
Our team of skilled personal injury lawyers in Flagstaff anticipates these tactics and will advocate on your behalf every step of the way. Contact us today to learn more about what representation you need to negotiate effectively with insurance companies.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/aa5d9/aa5d93fb831814def86c04308c3f41a0a3a4af9c" alt="AdobeStock_480051889 close-up of someone playing chess"
Anticipating the Insurance Company’s Tactics
We will develop a negotiation strategy to counter the insurance company’s strategies for minimizing your payout. We can help strengthen your case by researching and gathering evidence to ensure no crucial evidence is overlooked. We’re familiar with common negotiation tactics like lowball offers and delaying tactics, and we’re prepared to counter them effectively.
Having a skilled legal team can make all the difference. Schedule a free consultation with a personal injury attorney to help combat the tactics used by insurance companies to minimize payouts.
Building a Strong Negotiation Strategy
At Antol & Sherman, we excel at building strong negotiation strategies for personal injury cases. We start by assessing the value of your claim and carefully evaluating the extent of your injuries, the impact on your life, and your financial losses.
Next, we work with you to establish clear negotiation goals and priorities, ensuring that we align our strategy with your objectives.
We will then craft a persuasive argument supported by evidence to build a compelling case on your behalf. This included gathering all relevant documentation, such as medical records, expert opinions, and witness statements.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/06836/0683686cacb62a0a41f327b9cab647be4803ed61" alt="AdobeStock_369722200 lawyers around desk pointing at papers and ipads in strategy session"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bbc59/bbc59517fb8e90e8abeed5523709669ae3a81576" alt="gavel-on-court-desk-2021-12-09-09-42-59-utc gavel on court desk"
Knowing When to Take Action: Settlement vs. Litigation
It can be difficult to decide whether to accept a settlement offer or pursue litigation.
Factors to Consider When Deciding Whether to Accept a Settlement Offer
When deciding whether to accept a settlement offer, we recommend considering the following factors:
- The extent of your injuries
- The overall impact on your life
- The strength of your case
- The potential value of a trial verdict
Our legal team can advise whether a settlement offer is fair and reasonable.
Potential Outcomes and Risks of Litigation
Litigation involves risks and uncertainties. While going to trial may result in a higher potential payout, it also comes with the risk of receiving a lower verdict or losing the case altogether. We explain these potential outcomes and risks to help you understand the implications of pursuing legal action.
Make an Informed Decision with Guidance from Legal Experts
Making the decision between settlement and litigation requires careful consideration. At Antol & Sherman, we provide personalized advice based on our experience and knowledge of personal injury law. Our goal is to empower you to make informed decisions that align with your best interests.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/54322/543226458182642acf4f24a9e4e9d5b60a2c87e5" alt="2 (2) lawyer shaking hands with a person at a desk"
COMPASSIONATE & SKILLFUL REPRESENTATION IN NORTHERN ARIZONA
Antol & Sherman provides experienced and trustworthy representation for personal injury cases throughout Northern Arizona. Our team understands the importance of negotiating with insurance companies, anticipating their tactics, and building a strong negotiation strategy. We help clients navigate the decision between settlement and litigation. With our guidance, clients can make informed decisions and receive the maximum compensation for their injuries.
Schedule a consultation with a personal injury attorney in Flagstaff to discuss your case.
Our Specialties
Experienced Trial Attorneys in
FLAGSTAFF
The law firm of Antol & Sherman, PC is located in Flagstaff, Arizona. Our lawyers represent people throughout Northern Arizona in a variety of legal matters including:
• Criminal Defense, including DUI, drug
charges, violent crimes & serious felonies
• Family Law, including Child Custody,
Adoptions & Divorce
• DUIs – All types from first offense to
aggravated & felony DUI
Experienced Trial Attorneys in
Flagstaff
The law firm of Antol & Sherman, PC is located in Flagstaff, Arizona. Our lawyers represent people throughout Northern Arizona in a variety of legal matters including:
• Criminal Defense, including DUI, drug charges, violent crimes
& serious felonies
• Family Law, including Child Custody, Adoptions & Divorce
• DUIs – All types from first offense to aggravated & felony DUI
Free Initial Consultation
If you would like to speak to a member of our legal team regarding negotiating with insurance companies or another personal injury law issue, contact us online or call (928) 214-6339. Our experienced lawyers always offer initial consultations free of charge.